Sunday, 31 July 2011

What is cloning and why is it controversial?

I've arrived in the UK and am staying in Bournemouth for the next week. Although its a bit grey I'm told that a 'heat wave' is on its way!!!!. We had a really long flight getting here with a lot of reading and thinking time, and I thought it would be good to understand what exactly is cloning and why its controversial.

Cloning is the process of making an exact genetic copy of a being. In humans, clones can occur naturally as identical (monozygotic) twins. In 1997, scientists in Edinburgh successfully created a clone of a sheep using a process of somatic cell nuclear transfer implantation, where the nucleus of a mammary gland was placed into an unfertilized egg and implanted into the uterus of the mother to allow the pregnancy to develop. The resulting offspring was called “Dolly”.

I am going to go and visit Dolly when I get to Edinburgh and will blog a bit more about her when I get there.  But what was significant about Dolly was that her birth sparked a debate about whether cloning was ethical. Dolly was the first mammal to be cloned and made scientists as well as the public believe that cloning a human being could be possible. With this came the inevitable debate about whether it was ethical to clone a human being or parts of it. At the heart of this debate was the concept of scientists being able to “play god” by creating another human being and the human dignity of the clone or the cloned cells being created. The UN, UNESCO and the World Health Organization subsequently recommended bans on all forms of human cloning. Some forms of human cloning remain tightly regulated across the world. In the next few days I’m going to be exploring the different types of cloning (therapeutic and reproductive) to more fully understand the debate about the ethics of cloning.

Some general links about cloning are below:




Tuesday, 26 July 2011

Amazing footage- what stem cells can do.

I should be packing for my trip I know, but there's always shopping in London if I forget to bring something!!

I just found this cool link at the guardian UK website. It shows the embbryonic cells of mice forming an eye. I just think its amazing, and is a good example of what embryonic cells can do. But I am conflicted, because, if these were human embryonic cells, it could be akin to an organ factory. Any opinions out there???? How can we balance the magic of science of science with the ethical nature of the use of human cells? For me it comes down to beliefs and where these lie. I would like to think some may be able to compromise their values when you see the benefits of the treatments on people's lives. But I suppose this is one reason there is such controversy around human cloning- there are obvious opposing values. 

Enjoy the video.

Welcome to my blog!


Hello fellow bloggers!
Thanks for taking the time to read my blog. I’m currently studying a Graduate Diploma in Communication at the University of Queensland, and as part of my course I am exploring controversies in science. I’ve got an interest in medical science and what it can do to make our lives better. For me, the most intriguing developments in medical science in recent memory have been in the area of human cloning. 

There is much controversy regarding the ethics of human cloning and I want to explore this further in my blog over the next 10 weeks.  What makes it controversial??? It’s not just the science of human cloning that sparks debate, it’s whether we should interfere in the normal process of ageing and disease, whether we should or shouldn’t create life to save a life or address infertility issues for couples by cloning a child who is effectively the twin its mother. I’m starting on a journey (literally I’m flying to the UK tomorrow night!) of really exploring the issues from both sides about the ethics of human cloning. I hope you can come along with me……..

Things to look forward to in the next wee while...... in no particular order
  • What does the UN say about human cloning??? Do we agree on what we are using it for now?
  • Australian Law and other countries (I'm sure inspiration is going to come from my travels!!)
  • Dolly the sheep and what she did, and didn't do. I might even go and visit her in Edinburgh
Hope you enjoy...